Deep dish or thin crust? At Little Star Pizza, you can have both. Co-founders Jon Guhl and Brian Sadigursky designed a menu that features both thick, cheesy, Chicago-style pizza and thin, crispy pies …
The 9" Deep Dish was plenty when we paired it with a Small Goddess and the Small Roasted Cauliflower. It was plenty for two! There's not a thing I've ordered from here that I haven't loved. Huge fan, highly recommend!
J
Jamison S
11 contributions
4/28/24
• DoorDash order
First time ordering.
Food came in nice and fresh, even when Dasher had an additional stop to make. Packaging was of sturdy quality that kept the food safe, neat, and sealed.
The 9" Deep Dish Pizza is a good size for two meals (or one if you're really hungry). Very satisfying after 2-3 slices so you're less likely to overeat if that is an issue. Mine had sausages and chicken which were both great toppings. The chicken in particular was most satisfying as it was tender abd provided a nice bedding for all the cheese and tomato sauce to lay on. The crust was okay. More on the harder side when you get to the end, but provided a nice crunch. Not much to say in terms of flavor, but it provided good structure for the pizza and crunchy texture. Overall, satisfied.
The Chocolate Chip Cookie, however, left much to be desired. First, site says "deep dish cookie" but it looked like a normal big, flat cookie. What surprised me is that it tasted reminiscent to an oatmeal cookie, so I didn't get that traditional cookie flavor I was expecting. It also arrived fresh, but not warm, and had a nice soft texture. Could easily scoop out chunks with a spoon, which made it easy to eat it with the ice cream it came with. The ice cream was vanilla, but didn't have much vanilla flavor. Kind of like French Vanilla, but way less sweet and just a hint if vanilla. Ice cream was partially melted on arrival. Overall, just okay.
Total experience was still good. Wasn't too amazed, but it made for a satisfying dinner.
P
Paul A
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
5/31/25
• DoorDash order
The Pizza was just ok, it wasnt worth the price. Not to be meambut it was like Little Caesars. Chicken wings small, just like Little Caesars. Paid $53 I thought it would be different.
L
LEDIA M
2 contributions
2/18/22
• DoorDash order
Their deep dish is superior to Zachary's. Fabulous crust, Interesting combos, especially the ricotta & meatballs. Generous with the toppings. Avoid the thin crust for delivery if you're not close by. It gets cold. Sometimes they get the order wrong when you're requesting a substitution.
D
Dina S
1 contributions
2/23/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza was good. $8 for a slice of cheesecake that was smaller than a pizza slice is ridiculous. Never again.
