Pleasantly surprised it came as a personal pie and not as 2-slices shown. Chicken fingers were cooked perfectly!
It had a good coating of the citrus honey bbq sauce-- it's become a fav flavor of mine. =]
A
Allen L
7 contributions
3/29/25
• DoorDash order
Double Wings (20) Personal Cheese & 1 Topping wings were good Pizza was a little overcooked not worth $10 for that small of a pizza... blue cheese cup so small not used to that... and I guess nobody does celery anymore lol... definitely will keep ordering the wings I just will be mindful of what I order/Spend...
S
Sarah I
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
9/24/24
• DoorDash order
I was extremely impressed with how good everything was. I ordered from Macy's because it's the only pizzeria around that makes Battered Mushrooms (15) & they were delicious. I was skeptical about the pizza because I've heard opinions going both directions. However, the Small Cheese & 1 Topping pizza was excellent. I loved the sweet sauce. I just wish the mushrooms were evenly placed on the pizza. The Strawberry Cheesecake Logs (4) were to die for!!!! They were absolutely amazing.
This order was an awesome surprise of yumminess & I will be ordering from them again.
A
Anthony P
Local Expert • 24 contributions
12/2/24
• DoorDash order
Wings were perfect I ordered extra saucy and crispy and were perfec pozzawas also pretty good, for being a small personal its pretty filling and deent price!
C
Christa B
Local Expert • 53 contributions
5/1/24
• DoorDash order
Only giving 4/5 stars because 5 would indicate perfection, and that is never possible. My first time ordering from here was because I wanted to see what all the hype was about. I ordered the Macy's Macys Lunch Pack and it was so much food I actually shared with my neighbor. I ordered lemon pepper wings. Delicious! I did have a coupon where I received $5 off a $30 order so I added on the Personal Cheese & 1 Topping . My extra topping was bacon. delicious! the food was hot when it arrived. I was supposed to get two Pepsi', because I ordered an additional one, but only received one. There was supposed to be one included with the lunch special. I ended up with all this food for $25. I will definitely order from here again.
