Our special bagel recipe, which dates back over 50 years, yields the delicious fresh-baked bagels that our customers adore. We prefer to use farm-fresh eggs, premium meats, cheeses, and fresh fruit wh…
The challah French toast was phenomenal! They gave us 3 huge slices that were fluffy and had the right amount of sweetness and paired nicely withthe sauag. The amount of syrup given to us was very generous. The chicken sandwich was also great and packed with lots of flavor. I was surprised to see that they served it at 9 am . This restaurant has so many great things to offer for breakfast and lunch.
A
Algenis T
1 contributions
4/27/23
• DoorDash order
Ordered a bec on everything bagel toasted, a cream cheese bagel on everything toasted and tater tots. I received 2 toasted everything bagels plain-no cream cheese-cut in half instead of a single toasted everything bagel with cream cheese. The receipt also shows 1 bagel w/schmear. Didn't really bother me as I can just toast them and have them with butter. The reason for the 5 stars is the bec was soooo freaking good. Just moved to the area and no bagel place around Chatham/Madison area and beyond can come close to their bec. Also those tots were sooo delicious and plentiful. Def made up for the super tiny mishap.
J
Jailene G
2 contributions
6/6/23
• DoorDash order
The Caesar Salad is always my go-to! You tell the croutons are homemade and fresh. The chicken is always packed with flavor and the dressing is good, too. Highly recommend.
C
Catherine L
1 contributions
5/13/22
• DoorDash order
I moved away from NJ a few years ago and this is where I order when I come to visit. I'm never disappointed, and so happy to introduce my son to this fine NJ delicacy. I have eaten a lot of bagel sandwiches in my life, and Madison Bagel Cafe makes one of the BEST. I have a high standard for everything bagels and theirs is truly perfect. The center is soft and the outside is COVERED in seasoning. 10/10 highly recommend.
L
Laurie O
11 contributions
11/14/24
• DoorDash order
Eggs are burnt. The everything bagel is not as fruitful in spices as it used to be. All of a sudden they use oat in their everything bagels. There are no seeds or salt its bland and not worth the money. Delivery is always good but the product has demishished 100% not happy having to order from here but I have no choice.
