My favorite items are The Italian Sub and the NY Style Cheesecake. The subs are well made. Great bread. I like them with extra vinegar and they understand the assignment! Also the cheesecake is so creamy. Definitely my favorite.
A
Anthony F
Emerging Expert • 30 contributions
3/14/25
• DoorDash order
This was my first time ordering from Mangia in Toms River but it won't be the last. The pizza definitely reminded me of Brooklyn Pizza. The other item, Lasagna, was so much better than what I've ordered from other take-outs. It was close to home made, easy to recommend.
4 contributions
4/4/24
• DoorDash order
I can never get over how incredible this freaking pie is!! Typically if I order pizza for myself, I just grab a slice or two. But when it comes to this Grandma Brooklyn from Mangia, I grab an entire pie just so I can enjoy it for a couple days. top notch stuff!
M
Magdalena M
8 contributions
7/26/23
• DoorDash order
The Chicken Caesar Wrap was fantastic that my boufrjdn had- doesn't fall apart because they use a panini press and it was great he couldn't get over it & the Prosciutto Panini is my #1 go to and ive tried other things here (which are all so fresh and so good) and it (as always) was delicious ! The sides too for each meal were fresh and tasty + the Sautéed Spinach is AMAZING !! Def order here !
M
Mackenzie K
2 contributions
1/20/24
• DoorDash review
Mangia is SO SO SO GOOD. Lots of specialty pizzas and hands down BEST salad with lots of grilled chicken 😋
