It wasn't bad. $46 for A small sandwich, a huge baked potato and a piece of carrot cake delivered. The $14 sandwich was pretty small, bread was really soggy (partly Doordash's fault for squeezing in multiple deliveries in one trip), but it was stuffed with corned beef. The $14 stuffed potato was ENORMOUS--- but then they went really super chincy on the toppings, so much so that I had to go to the fridge to make it correctly. Which for a $5 baked potato is ok, but for a $14 baked potato it's pretty disappointing. All that said, it was excellent with the correct amount of toppings. The $7 carrot cake saved the day though. It was better than Cheese Cake factory's, and tasted amazing. It wasn't huge, but it was enough for my wife and I to split and both have a small piece. If they would portion the baked potato toppings and sandwich size properly this could be the best delivery deal out there. As it is though it's fairly decent.
B
Bethe B
21 contributions
11/26/24
• DoorDash order
The potato soup and BLT + Avocado is my go to when I'm not feeling good - which is weekly, lol. LOVE this deli!!! The new Butter Pecan Cheesecake is amazing!
S
Stacey S
9 contributions
8/6/24
• DoorDash order
Excellent meal for 1 person to eat twice. Love the Country Potato Soup! McAlister's Club always uses fresh meat & cheese! Brownie YUM!
B
Brenda S
3 contributions
12/27/24
• DoorDash order
Potato soup was bland and water . Club sandwich was dry. Normally like their food but spent $19 for a disappointing lunch that got thrown in the trash
E
Erika W
Emerging Expert • 45 contributions
12/21/24
• DoorDash order
Country Potato Soup was very bland and it made the meal nasty.Colossal Carrot Cake not good, very unappetizing and disappointing!