The Italian was magnificent!!! I would definitely order this again! Sweet and Smoky Chicken My daughter said it was amazing!Party Punch really good actually kind of surprised on how good it was.... And how large the drink was. Thank you! Lemonade My daughter said it tasted just perfect altogether! also I'm always skish about ordering anybody's potato salad... And this potato salad was absolutely delicious.... taste just like how my mom made it! perfect!!
P
Peggie M
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
7/5/25
• DoorDash order
First time trying McAlister’s and I’m impressed! The **club sandwich** was fresh and flavorful, but the stars were the **Buffalo Chicken Nachos** and the **loaded baked potato** with ham, turkey, and bacon — absolutely amazing. Great portions, bold flavors. Definitely ordering again!
S
Skye N
3 contributions
6/28/25
• DoorDash order
McAlisters always has a good mean for me when I need one. One of my favourite places to order from! The sandwich is well-sized, and it doesn't taste like it's been sitting out for days. Highly recommend.
S
Sheila C
1 contributions
6/29/25
• DoorDash order
Sandwich only had one tiny sliver of avocado and salad did not have any pecans
S
Sharie C
Local Expert • 53 contributions
4/30/24
• DoorDash order
First time having McAllister's and I now know why my friends all rave about it! The McAllister Club was delicious! I ordered the Choose 2 and got half a Spud Max and it was more food than I could eat! HIGHLY RECOMMEND! Everything was fresh and really good! Love the Tomato & Cucumber Salad!
