Mickeys Ice Cream Kitchen and Space, which opened in 2021 in the heart of St. James, is the soon-to-be iconic ice cream experience. The Fleming family has lived in St. James on Long Island's lovely no…
One of the best ice cream parlors around. Everything ive had is amazing! Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich (Single) is huge and delicious!
D
Daniel P
Local Expert • 40 contributions
4/7/25
• DoorDash order
Always love the ice cream here, and everything was great except for the Pint - Cherry Vanilla. My wife loves it and gets it every time, but this time she was disappointed. In the whole pint she said there were only 3 cherries. At almost 10 dollars a pint ifigure they could do better than that. But I guess things happen. Also, I always get the Topping- Peanut Butter Sauce (allergy) topping, but this time it had a very weird taste. I threw it out. But the other ice creams we got were amazing.
K
Karen C
Local Expert • 58 contributions
5/4/23
• DoorDash order
The icre Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich (Single) and the Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich (Single) were both good. giod sized cookies with a generous amount of ice-cream. The 2 and 3 scoop sundae cups were really really small. The three scoop cup is the size of a single scoop cup at other icecream places. They looked more like kid sized servings.
D
Demetri K
2 contributions
5/1/23
• DoorDash review
MICKEY'S!! BEST local ice cream shop in Saint James! (My ultimate 100% fav addition rite now ..lol. Peanut Butter Ripple in Vanilla!!! & Peanut Butter Overload!) Amazing ice cream.
S
Shea W
6 contributions
1/4/25
• DoorDash order
Great homemade ice cream, but the delivery orders are not consistent. I order the same thing every time and it's about a 50/50 chance of being correct. In person, they always make it right. The flavors are great. Would have rated 5 stars if not for the constant errors.
