The pie may not look like much especially when you just get a peice but it's the best out I've ever had. I've ordered a whole pie as well and was amazing. The soft serve also got here perfectly chilled even on the hottest of days. The peanut butter has a salty but realistic taste to it and the birthday cake is not to sweet. They never disappoint.
C
Caroline F
4 contributions
1/24/25
• DoorDash order
This is the second time I have ordered from this store and the B'day Cake Slice was stale. It is a delicious item that is ruined by this particular stores practices. Please pass along this feedback and refund until they get the message to only send fresh cakes
L
Lia W
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
12/15/24
• DoorDash order
Not sure if my expectations were too high or what but it was very underwhelming. The best item I had was the Milk Bar Pie Slice! Would get that again. I also got the 3 Cookie Deal and the corn cookie was terrible, i threw it away. The cornflake cookie and compost were good but I hated that they were prepackaged and not warmed at the very least? It seems kinda lazy but decent nonetheless. The Cereal Milk Soft Serve Cup was what I was most excited to try and it was the most underwhelming. It just tasted like regular vanilla ice cream. I honestly wouldnt waste your time going here. Try one of the other many local bakeries! Maybe it wouldve been better if I had it before the fame like other reviewers mention.
C
Caitlin L
1 contributions
8/9/24
• DoorDash order
This tasted like salty play dough, I was genuinely excited and then thoroughly disappointed. No other comment like trust me, order elsewhere lol
K
kiera m
1 contributions
7/8/24
• DoorDash order
tastes just like a real cake, strange crunchy gritty/ sandy bits on top though
