Mitsos and Papazickos renamed their firm "M&P Coney Island" in March 1971 after moving to a new location on the Diamond. In April 1972, a second restaurant opened in Neshannock Township.
Absolutely love the Our Famous Chili Dog and the French Fries! They always put such a generous helping of chili and it is always hot.
S
Sandra B
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
2/26/25
• DoorDash order
The food is alright for a hot dog stand. I would like the hot dogs cooked a little more. Nice portions and cost effective. Unfortunately, we consistently have issues with our orders, such as getting hot dogs instead of our ordered hamburgers and adding chili on items for someone who can't eat spicy.
R
Russell D
3 contributions
6/22/23
• DoorDash order
Best fish sandwich in town. Unique tarter sauce and just the right size. Love the old fashion style milkshakes
L
Lynn D
Emerging Expert • 51 contributions
9/18/22
• DoorDash order
The Chili Bean Soupwas stellar, still so hot on arrival. Also fries and hotdogs very good. Lotsa food will eat three meals
L
Leslie M
23 contributions
10/19/22
• DoorDash order
You guys are losing a ton of money on whoever is working the grill/frier tonight. Our orders were so overloaded with not only chili and cheese but fries also. Each order was at least a double size. Hotdog buns were all mushy and wet from the chili. The burgers weren't bad but not the best we've had at Coney Island. They had a different taste.
Definitely nothing like in the past.
