The salads were delicious! So fresh and packed full! Pizza was PERFECT!!
S
Sharon A
1 contributions
7/11/25
• DoorDash review
We had never ordered from Mr Gatti's before. We ordered a Sampler., a Meat Market and Garlic Sticks. It was cooked perfectly and loaded with toppings. We both said it was the best pizza we ever had.
J
Julie T
3 contributions
11/22/24
• DoorDash order
the box wasn't sealed when I received it & this is exactly how it looked when I opened the box.
the pics I saw before I ordered looked better than this. I was scared to taste it because of how I received it. disappointed for $40
S
Stephen P
6 contributions
6/28/25
• DoorDash order
there was barely any meat on a meat pizza, and they put sauce on to look like pepperoni. This place was great when it opened, but has lost me after two bad orders.
M
Melissa B
Emerging Expert • 59 contributions
12/9/23
• DoorDash order
Just ordered the Sampler paying extra for bacon and extra cheese. Paying for extra cheese seems to be like a visit from Santa, all imaginary. There was not much cheese on this. I would hate to see normal cheese or maybe this is a case of the Emperor's clothes. All in all it was not bad but not impressive. I think Luigi's is much better.
