We take pleasure in being your neighborhood pizza at My Pie. Our authentic New York pies are prepared to order from scratch utilizing family recipes. Local, fresh, and fast is our motto! We prefer to …
My pie never disappoints! Best pizza and Caesar salad in Dothan hands down!
A
Alicia S
Local Expert • 132 contributions
3/29/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza was burned. I ordered caramelized onions as a topping. 3 slices were piled Hugh with them and the other 3 had like 1 each.
T
Timothy B
6 contributions
3/27/25
• DoorDash order
It looks ok but it was more like cheese bread instead of a pizza, I seriously think they forgot to put any sauce on it. Always enjoyed the pies, but this one was a fail, glad I had something else to eat.
C
Carlton&Gretta C
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
6/23/23
• DoorDash review
Best pizza and salads in Dothan hands down! Toppings are super fresh & crust is just right, always delicious. The manager "Tiffany" is friendly, professional and is sure to greet everyone who walks in the door. The entire staff is courteous. We love my pie
K
Karen C
6 contributions
3/13/25
• DoorDash order
The pizza ingredients were good. However, I was disappointed that the olives were just placed on top, but werent cooked into the pizza. Every time I picked up a slice, all the olives fell off.
