New York Pizza & Pasta is a family-owned restaurant featuring fresh authentic Italian cuisine and home of the best New York-style pizza in SWFL. We use only the finest and freshest ingredients through…
Orig from NY area. This Pizza is really good!! The garlic bread is STRONG loved it. Arugala salad was surprisingly top notch.
M
Mary Ann Z
1 contributions
1/1/25
• DoorDash order
Fettuccine Alfredo was excellent - creamy, thick sauce with pasta not overcooked.
Garlic Knots had a nice bread for the base, but the garlic (fresh, which is usually great), was overcooked and bitter, so these were disappointing.
Small NYPP Salad was nice, balsamic dressing wasn't too sweet or too tangy and produce was very fresh.
A
Aileen B
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
9/30/24
• DoorDash order
When dinning in the restaurant ask for the stuffed artichoke!! It's not on the menu but it's the best I've ever had and it's huge!!! Pasta is outstanding also. In the summer Tuesday was 1/2 price pasta day. Best pizza in town!!!
M
Mary Beth G
1 contributions
6/14/24
• DoorDash order
The Caesar salad at NYPP is always great -- the salad dressing is THE best! the 239 pizza (thin crust) is also amazing - just the right amount of hot honey! Highly recommend NYPP!
S
Sandra M
4 contributions
11/17/24
• DoorDash review
Very underwhelming. Garlic bread and knits were undercooked and overpowering with garlic, so much so we couldn’t eat them. Caesar salad was below average, pizza was ok and cost $32. Disappointing overall.
