Authentic New York Style Pizza by the Slice, Whole Pie, Calzone & Salads. Our freshly made dough, locally sourced Mozzarella cheese, homemade sauce, quality ingredients and excellent service is what s…
Pizza was Amazing Always Loved this place. Pizza was Hot and delicious. Will order it again.
J
Jamie P
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
5/12/25
• DoorDash order
The The sauce provided across the board was overly sweet. The Cheesy Garlic Bread was inedible - loaded with jarred old minced garlic that made me concerned it had somehow gone off.
The Cheese 12 Inch (Small) was also loaded eiththe jar garlic, the added toppings were sparse I thought they'd left the meatballs off, the sauce was cloying and the crust was somehow over crisp and soggy at the same time. All the savory items were indelibly salty (and I like salt).
The NY Cheesecake slice tasted like playdoh and the color and flavor indicated it was probably previously frozen and left out after thawed. Was small but didn't eat it so I guess it doesn't matter.
I ould never order from here again no matter how late or hungry.
This also appears to share a kitchen with Calzone and all of that food was just as bad.
P
Phil B
1 contributions
6/30/24
• DoorDash review
Totally hungry wanted something fast and what I thought was close. New York Pizza is 5.4 miles away. I dunno, sounds close to me. Go to order and they have an additional charge for my location. There are enough hidden fees in my daily life, don't need it in my 12" medium pizza order... PASS!!!
S
Summer M
1 contributions
2/27/24
• DoorDash order
This pizza was so good! Perfectly cooked and the best last night snack.
