This was my first time ordering from here, and I really enjoyed the food. The 14" Cheese pizza was good! I ordered the thin crust and this pizza has a very thin crust just the way I like it! The Quesadilla had a lot of flavor! I will definitely order from here again!
T
Thomas P
4 contributions
8/1/25
• DoorDash order
I have always enjoyed Nick and Stellas pizza. Sauce is great and plenty of toppings. This last order of the 16 inch pizza fell short of expectations.The dough was so stretched thin that it couldn't be held in my hand to eat. Had to use a knife and fork. Also it was cut lopsided. Half of the slices were much shorter than the rest. It was still tasty and the wings were great so only dropped it 1 star. I will definitely order from them again.
R
R K
Local Expert • 289 contributions
1/28/25
• DoorDash order
the jerk sauce for the 10 Wings was still in powder in the little containers, dipped into it and all I tasted was salt. the ranch dressing was terrible. tasted like it was made with fat free mayo etc etc. terrible..
the 10 Wings themselves were not. done enough. have potential. many of the celery sticks were old and scarred.
the Lg Greek Salad was not the best by a long shot. had a lotta pickles that were some odd sweet flavor. the cukes looked like they had been partially frozen from all the discoloration on them. not enough peppers, ranch is one of the worst I ever tasted. the whole thing --- ick ,
a complete waste of money. I paid extra for sauces and for extra celery, don't waste your money and time.
P
Paul F
6 contributions
2/22/25
• DoorDash review
always a great pizza from a wonderful restaurant here in Fort Myers Florida.
T
Thomas P
4 contributions
5/24/25
• DoorDash order
Food is always great. Nice portions and good prices.
