Absolutely am obsessed with their original crust. I don't think I've had others like it yet. It even reheats beautifully and is still crisp and soft and amazing. This is the only pizza where it's guaranteed that I will always have the whole slice and crust. The sauce is also my favorite ever! Also sometimes get a little hint of some heat in the sauce, maybe some kind of crushed red pepper, but really like that, they should consider making a pizza that has a sauce with more of whatever that is that the heat is from, would love that!
V
Vickie S
Local Expert • 51 contributions
3/3/23
• DoorDash order
The Steak and Cheese sub was DELICIOUS! The sub roll was fresh! Plenty of steak and toppings! I had saute' onions, saute' mushrooms, Provolone cheese and mayo. I could only eat half of the sub, The potato skins were good! I could only eat two of them. The potato skins were a good size and you get a good portion size. Would recommend!
J
Jennifer M
2 contributions
7/27/25
• DoorDash order
usually, we love Nicolettis, but tonight wasn't it. The pizza was ordered well done but was soggy. the Pepperoni Rolls were either soggy or overcooked. Plus it took forever - and it wasnt Door Dash's fault. I dont recommend ordering the thin crust pizza!
A
Aleigha H
3 contributions
10/17/24
• DoorDash order
Pizza was very good. Always flavorful and baked to perfection. Even the crust is enjoyable . First time trying the Alfredo, which was just okay. Was hoping for more flavor but it seemed a bit bland, where the heavy-cream really overpowered other ingredients. Overall, not bad and would get again! :)
F
Felicia S
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
1/12/25
• DoorDash order
Had the Calzone! Outstanding! Flavors aren't overpowering; simply perfect. Love that I can add extra ricotta cheese. Well cooked! Thank you for a lovely culinary stimulating experience. Will order again and again.
