Pizza tastes fresh, savory, and flavorful. Nice light, chewy, crispy texture on the crust. A hint of garlic and herbs. Canoli is huge!
D
Durand W
5 contributions
11/22/23
• DoorDash order
Have enjoyed all the food from here. Nonna Ilva Pizza I was expecting to be different but was very good. Was expecting a meat sauce instead of meat lovers. Best pizza dough and cheese I've had in Carlisle. Caprese Salad was tasty and fresh, kids loved it.
J
Justice S
1 contributions
2/27/24
• DoorDash order
this is now my favorite spot in Carlisle to order pizza. they go the extra mile with customer service and each pizza is SO DELICIOUS! the Vegetariana Pizza is now my favorite as the ingredients taste fresh and high quality. even on Monday. prices are great for what you get too imo.
A
Amy E
9 contributions
7/17/25
• DoorDash order
The Cheese Pizza and French Fries were perfect as always. Consistently tasty and fresh, Nonna's is my go-to when I'm craving some good pizza! The price is right to boot, as those pizzas, even the medium ones, can fill up my partner and I for two meals on most days! (That said, the larges are equally worth the price, especially if you've got several folks to feed.) Better than any chain's pizza, that's for sure. And usually at a better price these days, too! Better pizza, for less money? Aww yeah, man. As for the fries, I admit they might be pricey at first glance, but they are delicious enough to be worth every penny, in my personal opinion. Their ingredients are top notch, and I know from going to the store myself and speaking with the staff that the owner places high priority on making sure it stays that way, while also doing his best to keep prices reasonable to support our local community. Support the heck outta these guys so they can hopefully stick around here for years to come!
B
Becky M
16 contributions
7/7/25
• DoorDash order
My husband and I decided to try Nona Ilva during a 2 for 1 special. Hands down the best Fettuccine Bolognese and Cheesy Garlic Bread we've had in the area period! You get plenty of pasta for your money! We both had leftovers the next day. The Cheesy Garlic Bread was so warm fresh and soft it paired perfectly with the Bolognese. I would love to try the Carbonara next time and dont get me startedbon the the Cannoli! They were absolutely devine! we are planning on ordering exclusively dessert based on those alone!
