New York J&P Pizza is an Italian pizzeria and restaurant serving authentic meals every day. Dine-in or order online for takeout and delivery! Benvenuto and welcome to New York J&P Pizza! Owner Frank I…
We are obsessed with their 18" Buffalo Chicken Pizza!! SOOOOOO good! We do extra sauce and extra cheese. Bumps the price but it's worth it to us! Yum!!!
P
Patrick P
Local Expert • 22 contributions
7/7/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza is excellent! This is only place in Frederick where you're gonna get sliced Italian sausage instead of those horrible crumbles.
D
Denise L
1 contributions
12/18/21
• DoorDash order
If you love eating gourmet iceberg then this is your salad!! Oodles of iceberg lettuce, one sliver of onion, two to three croutons, one slice of cucumber, two slivers of mushy tomato and invisible grilled chicken! $8.79 is a steal!
Onto the $7.15 mozzarella bread...where do I begin. Who could resist mozzarella bread prepared on a gourmet sub roll topped with coagulated hard mozzarella.
Bang up job guys!
K
Karla M
Local Expert • 94 contributions
7/29/24
• DoorDash order
If you're looking for an all-around nice Italian meal sit down we love j&p. this will be the second time that we've gotten delivery and it does not translate well. Fried mushrooms were soggy because the lids have no vent. Pizza was cold and the cheese separated from the sauce. order was placed at 4:17 and delivered at 5:45. The shrimp crab fondue has great flavor. The shrimp were large but still had the tail shells on them. Good food if you're looking for a place to eat in. Do not get the delivery.
K
Kelli D
10 contributions
7/31/25
• DoorDash order
So glad I found this place! Sauce is excellent, meatballs are huge, pizza is excellent and the chicken parm was delicious!
