NYP Slice House brings passion and perfection in pizza whether you choose the New Yorker or the sweet and spicy Eddie Muenster, NYP Slice House will not disappoint. All of our ingredients are authenti…
After a long week of hotel living - complete with disappointment after disappointment for dinner from area restaurants - I have finally found something great! The Mediterranean calzone is a perfect combination of flavors wrapped up in a delicious crust! They were even kind enough to add some pepperoni to it even though there was not an option for charging for extra ingredients when ordered on door dash. The marinara has just the right heat for a calzone sauce and the portions are just right!!! I can't wait to dig into the chocolate dipped mini cannoli!! I'll be spending some time in cruces and I can't wait to start trying the rest of the menu!!! Thank you for restoring my faith in restaurant food!!!
H
Helena R
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
3/2/25
• DoorDash review
VERY PRICEY. Medium Chicago & a "build your own" medium pizza. The medium size is smaller than other pizzerias, which was disappointing. Their red sauce is good, although I've had better. We ordered a pizza with mushrooms and guess what? NO MUSHROOMS were on the pizza. On there on-line menu (not the Door Dash menu), they have listed a St. Anthony pizza with mushrooms. We were attempting to recreate that pizza. Mushrooms are listed as an up-charge of $1.65 on DD menu. If y'all don't have mushrooms, take them off the menu.
One more note: the toppings are sparse. They use tiny pepperoni (great flavor) and chunky Italian sausage. The sausage chunks need to be smaller and more spread out over the pizza. The ricotta also. I more than likely will not order again.
M
Melody H
Emerging Expert • 31 contributions
11/8/24
• DoorDash order
I love that they allow you to customize a little. And the Eddie Muenster is absolute perfection. Salty. Sweet. Smoky. Spicy.
Also best pizza crust in town. Chewy and flavorful.
G
Gwendolyn R
3 contributions
11/17/24
• DoorDash order
Quality issue! Only 4-5 very small, broken pieces of mushroom were on my pizza. The sausage was also quite skimpy...not worthwhile, especially for what they charge. Very disappointing; I will not order from here again.
B
Becca G
9 contributions
8/31/23
• DoorDash review
Excellent pizza. Thin crispy crust on the veggie with a perfect sauce and topping ratio. Pepperoni has 'the good pepperoni' with crispy edges and a nice bite. Real salad too, not just lettuce. Nice place, cute decor. Great service. It was busy and she was running the front really well.
