My colleague and I were looking for a really good Cheesesteak. I did a little googling and this one came up with pretty good reviews. it definitely lived up to the reviews. Cheesesteak done right FINALLY!!! We loved it. we expected a little bigger for the price but it was really good. I like that they gave the option of cheese. we had the Cooper sharp American. perfect balance of meat & cheese. good bread, too. I'm definitely ordering again when I need a fix.
D
Dana M
Emerging Expert • 32 contributions
3/31/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered cheesesteak from Olde City for the very first time to try it out with a friend Monday early afternoon. We absolutely loved it. I enjoyed it so much I was craving it and ordered again Sunday about 10pm. It was not quite the same. Last time it was a perfect balance of meat with not too much cheese. Unfortunately, this time it was overwhelming with cheese. It ruined it for me. It makes me wonder do they have specific instruction for the recipe or do the cooks freestyle the recipe. Consistency is key with food. Now I am scared to try again. I don't know which of the two versions I would get. especially at $20 a pop.
C
Cathy S
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
12/30/24
• DoorDash order
I wish they kept the Cheddar cheese option. That's still my favorite, and I've tried all the cheese options.
S
Susan W
2 contributions
8/27/23
• DoorDash order
We needed a late night meal. The Buffalo was AMAZING! Mild sauce, ranch, and American cheese. SO good.
A
Andres M
1 contributions
6/12/24
• DoorDash order
The best cheesesteak in town by far! The old bay fries are phenomenal and perfectly crispy and seasoned. Love this place!
