First time trying One Pie Pizza.. && I guarantee it will NOT be the last. The 2 Large Slice Special is totally worth the price. Each slice is huge, generously loaded with toppings, & I am SUPER HAPPY that I picked this spot! Full to capacity!
M
Melody L
4 contributions
6/29/25
• DoorDash order
1/2 sheet is perfect for 3-4 people
got the extra bake and would recommend and the toppings are fire
the sauce is a little sweet and uneven. with the munchies tho. with the munchies tho
B
Betty B
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
5/14/24
• DoorDash order
The Pineapple BBQ Chicken & Bacon Pizza was one of the tastiest pizzas ever! Great combination of fresh ingredients. I like how they seal the box for delivery. I wish more places did that. The salad was fresh also.
L
Lori K
2 contributions
7/5/25
• DoorDash order
Flight attendant here, so I eat all over the U.S. which has made me a foodie....I always opt for thin crust but chose One Pie based on the locals teviews......SO GLAD I DID! Fresh, amazing flavor, and huge portions. This place is going in my notes for future BUF layovers :)
M
Marques R
3 contributions
9/15/24
• DoorDash order
I ordered two large slice specials and one large sausage slice. The two slices of pizza are phenomenal. The crust is beautiful on both sides, flavorful, and the blue cheese. The blue cheese is the best blue cheese I've had in a long time, and that's a big thing, coming from me, being from Buffalo. Highly highly highly recommend
