The Original Anthony's NY Pizza in Casselberry, a culinary gem, has been a cornerstone in the Casselberry, Maitland, and Winter Park area for 37 years. Established as the original store of what would …
absolutely Fabulous. spaghetti need a little more sauce but 10 out of 10. The portions sizes is amazing like I will order this every week. Cheese - 16″ Large (8 Slices) . pizza slices are so huge and delicious. New York Cheesecake was delicious. and French Fries was well seasoned and delicious ... omg I'm actually very pleased.... best order on doordash yet
R
Rebecca F
4 contributions
6/23/25
• DoorDash order
The best pizza place I've found in Orlando area and I have tried a lot of them between Altamonte, Casselberry, and Oviedo. They slice actual meatballs on your pizza -- not just chunks of ground meat. The slices are huge, and delicious. Would I order again? Yes. Yes. Yes!
A
Alex S
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
9/25/24
• DoorDash order
That "small" Small Calzone - Create Your Own is anything but small! And it's soooooo good, I just wish they would add some seasoning to the cheese so that I don't have to rely on the crust's amazing flavor.
K
Kelley P
Local Expert • 76 contributions
2/16/24
• DoorDash order
Would have been a 4-5 star review because the Fettuccini Carbonara was wonderful and huge portion. However, the garlic knots were dry and hard so I threw them out and I did not receive the Strawberry Cheesecake so there's that.
H
Heather C
7 contributions
5/9/22
• DoorDash order
Everything was amazing! This is the third night we've ordered from Anthony's NY Pizza. The meatballs are incredible. We've ordered them all three times. Their Pasta is the best I've had and I've had a lot of pasta from many different places.We'll definitely order from here again!
