Ze best seasoned pizza I know locally, as long as it's not the Shaq'aroni pizza. Way too much pepperoni to experience much else from flavor. I personally recommended the New York style crst if you liked Domino'sbrooklyn style.
C
Catherine G
2 contributions
7/13/24
• DoorDash order
The Meats Pizza was terrible. i paid for extra cheese. The pizza barely had any toppings on it and there were spots in the middle with no cheese. There was a two inch border of crust with no toppings. Very disappointed. This Papa Joins has been going downhill. Cheesesticks were OK.
M
Macon H
1 contributions
3/14/25
• DoorDash order
First time ordering from here, so not sure how often this happens but the pizza I ordered had a big spot where it bubbled up and ruined 2 of the pieces as it's just hard and overcooked dough now. Surprised it got past quality control like this as it definitely did not happen during delivery.
The crust on this pizza was incredible though.
B
Bethani S
4 contributions
2/15/24
• DoorDash order
Rall love the garlic parm wings. Love the flavor. However. ONCE AGAIN my cheesey bread was burnt to a CRISP at the edges. A good half inch border of stiff cardboard. I swear if yall weren't the ONLY pizza place that delivers to me I would NEVER order from picayune papa johns. Quality at this store is ZERO
