Papa Johns Pizza (955 Indiana Avenue)
4.3(9k+ ratings)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
Temporarily closed on DoorDash
4.3(9k+ ratings)•
$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
10:00 am - 11:44 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Reviews9k+ ratings • 70+ public reviews
4.3
of 5 stars
C
Christopher M
4 contributions3/16/25
• DoorDash orderCheese sauce was room temperature. Whereas, other Papa Johns keep theirs cold. Not sure whether to be concerned about that or not. Tasty pizza though.
J
J C
2 contributions12/31/24
• DoorDash orderMy order was wrong. I got the wrong side...and only one. I ordered the pizza well done as it was an option given. It was undercooked and doey. There was about three pieces of stringy spinach on it. I asked for extra sauce on tge pizza. This was also a box to check as an option. There was ZERO. It wasn’t even covered in cheese on a 1/4 of the pizza. I had to cook the brownies in the oven bc they werent done all the way tgr and you cou ev get themoff tgetin they came in. I also put the pizza in a skillet to krisp it up. That woekedwell to salcagethe overpriced disaster tgatarriced at my door.
S
Stephanie R
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions7/10/24
• DoorDash orderunderrated, the crust was soft and doughy, pale in color. I don't want we'll done but I want the pie cooked. the toppings were under cooked as well, cheese barely melted.
A
Alexea W
4 contributions11/29/23
• DoorDash orderPapa Johns is normally a fav of mine, but tonight the crust tasted completely different . Like cheap Walmart crust. Sadly the breadsticks were burned and didn't even come with any of the cheese I ordered.
L
Latraneice R
6 contributions4/12/23
• DoorDash orderJalapeño bites were very good and cheesy. Oreo bites are highly not recommended. They need to use better breading for dessert bites. Italian Papadia was very delicious with the garlic butter sauce!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store