Insanely good gluten free food. A real crust that doesn't taste like cardboard in comparison to most gf crusts in Pittsburgh. The Pastoli's Italian Gluten Free Wedgie was my favorite. Cant wait to order again.
J
Jason F
1 contributions
6/13/25
• DoorDash order
Pastoli’s has been a real treasure trove for us to find. First, they have an extensive menu that covers anything from appetizers to calzones, wings, pizza, hoagies and much, much more! Secondly, it’s easy to add items like olives or remove items like mushrooms from a Philly cheesesteak hoagie. Lastly, it tastes great. Everything we’ve ordered has tasted great, arrived hot and fresh and also orders with toppings left off or added on correct upon arrival. The MOST important reason we love Pastoli’s is their gluten free and allergen friendly items!! My wife has celiac disease and cannot consume gluten. She’s very sensitive to gluten so we have to be careful of cross contamination. We always call a new place before ordering so we can ask about their gluten free items and how they prepare them. When we called Pastoli’s they were friendly, answered questions quickly and gave detailed replies. We are always still slightly concerned until she eats it and doesn’t get ill. When the first order arrived she declared it as delicious, amazing, had a wonderful actual pizza crust that was like its gluten containing counter-part. After a few hours we knew that they truly do gluten free properly as she didn’t get sick. Since then we have ordered several times and everything we’ve ordered has been delicious and she hasn’t been ill. She’s raved about Pastoli’s to her fellow celiac disease friends. One time there was a slight hiccup and we received three calzones instead of one and we called to let them know and they quickly apologized and we inquired if the pizza was correct (due to the mixup we just wanted to be sure) and learned when there are gluten containing items are ordered with gluten free items they mark the gluten free items with a “GF”. So we instantly knew again how seriously they take preparing their gluten free items (and allergen friendly items as well we’re sure). So if you are reading this and looking for tasty gluten free items that are prepared safely definitely give Pastoli’s a try - you won’t be sorry! Many of the places we’ve tried she might enjoy something and I don’t like much there or she gets sick and I love it there. It’s been a gift to find somewhere we both are happy and can both enjoy the food we order. Thanks, Pastoli’s, for getting gluten free right and having a ton of items to choose from whether it’s the regular menu, allergen-friendly or gluten free one. To the person reading this review stop reading and start ordering!! You will be enjoying wonderful food and making Pastoli’s a new favorite of yours!!
C
Christopher M
16 contributions
2/27/25
• DoorDash order
My favorite gluten-free place in the city, love it, order it constantly. Great pizza, wings, sandwiches, everything. The Gluten Free Pizza - 4 Cut pizza has a slim crust, and it's especially good -- with pepperoni and sausage.
J
Jennifer B
2 contributions
2/17/25
• DoorDash order
Pastoli's is one of my favorite pizza places and never disappoints! The buffalo chicken pizza is great and the pepperoni rolls are the best I've ever had!
L
Linda L
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
6/5/23
• DoorDash order
The side Tossed Salad was THE MOST high quality salad I've ever had from a pizza place, and even many restaurants. Fresh mixed greens, fresh mozzarella, olives, and more, and not a single scrap of iceberg lettuce. The Cheesy Garlic Bread was huge and very good, but not garlicky enough for me. My son said his cheese pizza was very good too.
