I had the create your own grilled Dagwood and it was top notch. Bread was like a French baguette. Fries are so so good. Comparable to Five Guys. And one of the best chocolate chip cookies I have ever eaten. Trust me, get the cookie.
K
Kirsten K
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
9/6/24
• DoorDash order
I honestly expected way better. Won't get this again. My large share fry was overcooked tiny Fresh-Cut Fries and only half the container was full and the Classic Grilled Italian had the worst flavor and what felt like a half cup of salt. I'll just get subway from now on, my kids gave it to the dog... wasted $40
R
Robb S
2 contributions
12/21/24
• DoorDash order
I was expecting for $19 to have a delicious sandwich with portions large enough to last for dinner tonight and lunch tomorrow. I also expected mustard and mushrooms as well as pizza sauce. however I didn't see or taste any of those ingredients. I also expected a similar amount of meat as the photo, but I was sadly disappointed. I was too hungry not to eat what I ordered, but I don't think that I will order delivery as my experience in store is much better than delivery.
K
Kimberly S
2 contributions
1/14/25
• DoorDash order
Lettuce was left off and the amount of meat and cheese was just sad. Also, for some reason, this store stopped offering turkey a few months ago. Even if you try to add it, you'll get an error message. The sandwich was way overpriced for what you get.
J
James H
1 contributions
12/14/23
• DoorDash order
Ordered a BLT with extra bacon and there were two strips of bacon on the entire sandwich. Will not be ordering from Penn Station again. Feel like they charged me extra for the extra bacon and subtracted bacon from the sandwich.
