I haven't had Penn station in years ugh. My dad and I used to get it every Sunday before the walking dead would air on AMC. I MISS THIS SO MUCH!!! Subway could never... ever never. Lord knows I will crave this for the rest of my life. I GOT THE Classic Grilled Italian !! I removed pepperoni and cold bell peppers. I added pickles. It's just too good to be true man.... I could shed a tear. Not to mention this Sweet Tea I got as well?? Oh. My. Gosh. I like it better than mcdonald's Sweet Tea. Mark my words, dont sleep on Penn Station.
M
Maggie L
1 contributions
7/10/22
• DoorDash order
I'm visiting my friends and wanted to try something that I don't have in my town so this was my first experience with this place: the fries were typical sandwich shop, nothing particularly special, but quite tasty, if a little too greasy,, but the sandwich-a chicken cheesesteak-was exceptional! I'm typically a pretty fast eater, but I absolutely inhaled this thing because it was too delicious not to. And I got a small fry and a medium sandwich to be safe, and although I was worried everything would be too small, I'm glad I went with that because it actually ended up almost being *too much* food for me, so if you like good portions, this is definitely the place for you!
F
Felicia A
Emerging Expert • 19 contributions
8/19/23
• DoorDash order
Salad was thrown together. Meat wasn't cut up. There was very little lettuce. The avocado spread should have been a generous dollop. The salad was Not worth the money. Disappointing.
T
Tiara W
2 contributions
5/31/25
• DoorDash order
It didnt taste like my bread had been grilled at all. And the meat didnt have any real seasoning and Ive never ever had an issue like that from any Penn Station Ive been to. Also the lemonade tasted like there was soap in it. Maybe from just cleaning the machine or something but the taste was definitely off.
T
Thomas E
Emerging Expert • 33 contributions
1/27/25
• DoorDash order
The last time I ordered Grilled Club, it was great.This time, it was extremely dried out, no lettuce, and wrong kind of cheese. Ddash gave me $5 back for a $14+ sand.
