the wings are a lil on the small side and personally i think they need a bit more sauce when tossed but theyre pretty good, just what you want with pizza. the Chicken Ranchero Pizza is amazing 12/10 i love the new yorker too but this one is definitely a new favorite. crust is soft but crispy, cheese is gooey, chickens seasoned well and tender, and the alfredo is really good. thank you pepperoni's <3
M
Mallori G
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
12/7/23
• DoorDash order
Overall, I am pleasantly surprised! The Garlic Bread With Cheese had fantastic flavor, as did the marinara. The bread was slightly dry, but the flavor certainly made up for that. The Chicken Ranchero Pizza had wonderful flavor and the perfect amount of toppings. I don't eat pork, so I got the pizza without bacon and still had plenty of flavor. As for the Cannoli, I was expecting it to be one of those disappointing "cream at the ends" situation, but it was filled all the way through. The cream was delicious, the pastry flavorful, but the pastry was a little thicker and also a tad overbaked. Overall, it's hard to beat Pepperoni's for the price and variety!
L
Laurel A
Local Expert • 44 contributions
8/25/23
• DoorDash order
As someone from upstate NY this is the best pizza I've gotten since moving here. As for the Mozzarella Sticks I really wanted to like them because they're a classic you know but I didn't like these, the breading has a weird texture and the taste is off almost burnt but the pizza is 10/10.
C
Cindy G
5 contributions
11/28/23
• DoorDash order
I just found my new favorite pizza place! New Yorker Pizza had Amazing taste. Fresh cheese. Perfectly balanced marinara sauce. Garlic Bread With Cheese is to die for. Tip: Order a couple of extra cups of marinara.
S
Sydney W
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
2/23/24
• DoorDash order
I would have included pictures b it j ate everything SO fast! Loved the Pepperoni Rolls (especially the garlic/butter/parmesan combo) and there was about 6-8 of them. The Cheese Pizza BYO I made with just a classic pepperoni and cheese was also delicious and to finish it off, the Cannoli was just what I needed!
