Bread is paramount for great sandwich, and Pickleman's is top notch. Meats and vegetables also excellent quality. Best Italian club style sandwich in the city that I've found, and I've done my research.
C
Courtney B
Local Expert • 33 contributions
3 days ago
• DoorDash order
Didn't love the Pickle. Pickled/taste to it is interesting and not what I expected... not a classic taste but its okay. #8 Cafe Club Sandwich was delicious and definitely worth the $8 sale I got. Tastes fresh and good portion. Didn't love jalapeno cheddar Chips though but might just be a me thing. They weren't really spicy. Would order #8 Cafe Club Sandwich with different chips again.
S
S C
3 contributions
7/30/25
• DoorDash order
The first time I ordered from them it was great, which propelled me to order again the very next day. This time it was terrible. The wheat bread was hard, there was an extreme amount of lettuce, one slice of turkey and the smallest amount of mayo and mustard. It was dry and disappointing after having a good experience the first time. They need to be consistent.
M
meriam A
1 contributions
7/14/25
• DoorDash order
the drink we ordered did not arrive, and the box lunch was not actually a box, it was just the sandwich and chips. but the food itself was correct and tasted good. the sandwich size was enough to fill me up. the ingredients seemed fresh and the lettuce was not wilty. willing to order again because it tasted good.
L
Lori D
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
11/12/24
• DoorDash review
Chicken Bacon Ranch Mac&Cheese is so good and always delivered warm to hot.
#11 Italian sandwich is really good as well.
