#11 Italian Club Sandwich Holy yumminess! Absolutely terrific sandwich! I can't even believe how good it was. I kept going mm with almost every bite! The Broccoli Cheese soup was pretty darn tasty as well and the roll was great! Everything was very hot and fresh when it arrived. Very happy 🙏
H
Heather C
2 contributions
6/29/25
• DoorDash order
I really wanted to like this, in part because I appreciate the range of sandwiches they offer. The sandwiches were OK, well packaged, and arrived quickly. but honestly the bread was surprisingly skinny (as compared to the pictures), more like the size of a baguette than deli sandwich bread, and kind of dry. The Cuban sandwich was so thin on cheese I had to peel it apart to make sure that it was there. it was also so heavy on the mustard that's mostly all I could taste. The Italian sub was fine, but if I hadn't ordered double salami, it might've been pretty thin on the meat? Also, if you like oil and vinegar on your Italian sub, as I do, I suggest adding extra. I'm probably biased as a former New Yorker, but I honestly could get either of these sandwiches at any corner bodega for less money and double the size.
P
Piper H
Local Expert • 46 contributions
5/17/25
• DoorDash order
The sandwich was very good! The Mac and cheese was good but so so tiny! Def not worth the price. The lemonade was good, but they forgot my salad completely.
R
Richea M
1 contributions
12/15/24
• DoorDash order
For a $10 sandwich, the turkey bacon club barely has anything on it. Pretty disappointing.
S
Sabrina H
1 contributions
7/2/25
• DoorDash order
i absolutely love picklemans but i didn't get as much chipotle ranch as i normally do and i don't think they put oil and vinegar like i asked therefore leaving it dry and bland. but the ingredients as always super fresh and my cucumbers are crispy. i would absolutely order again i was just disappointed with the amount of oil and vin and ranch i got.
