Brooklyn Reuben this was an excellent sandwich. There was a lot of meat on it. You definitely could tell the meat was cooked in house. My only complaint was there wasn't enough dressing as it had soaked into the bread. I also got the pasta salad which wasn't my favorite as it had too much vinegar.
When I got the sandwich it was a little soggy but I think it was because it was delivered instead of hot in the restaurant. It was so big I have lunch for tomorrow.
This place is definitely worth the visit, I just wouldn't have it delivered.
Go try it, you won't be disappointed!
C
Cindy C
Emerging Expert • 62 contributions
4/23/25
• DoorDash order
Great liverwurst sandwich! Everything is always great!
J
Jennifer S
2 contributions
3/27/25
• DoorDash order
Huge delicious sandwich! My husband asked where I bought it from and instantly looked it up and said when are we going AGAIN?! Classic ReubenPickle Barrel great selection and very savory!
M
Michele S
3 contributions
3 days ago
• DoorDash order
We dine in at Pickles often and have never been disappointed. First time delivery was fine. Food arrived warm and while the french fries were a bit limp it is to be expected as they basically steamed in the container on the way to the house. Choose a different side for delivery. Sandwiches were great.
T
Tommy W
3 contributions
3/27/25
• DoorDash order
Love this place and the food is always great. Tuna wrap and Grandma's Chicken Soup is very good
