To quote my fiance, "They are the only ones who have ever given us the right amount of cheese sauce... EVER!" Generous portions and mouth watering flavors, you can't go wrong. They do not hold back the heat with their Dragon (spicy!) so make sure you are a real spicy lover; we are and we loved it. The full size Hot Honey Pepperoni Sticks may seem pricy at first, but they were about the same size as a 10 inch pizza and absolutely delicious.
L
Liam T
3 contributions
8/24/24
• DoorDash order
this is the 2nd time I've ordered from pizza uncommon and their pizzas truly do not disappoint. we got the Meat Monster and the Crab Rangoon pizzas this time. i gotta say the Meat Monster is all the flavor and none of the heartburn of a meatlovers. and the crab rangoon really is uncanny in flavor to the one from any chinese place except perhaps not greasy and guaranteed crispyness.
G
Greg K
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
8/6/24
• DoorDash order
I ordered the Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza on gluten-free crust with cashew milk mozzarella and also added mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Also, the apple Apple Crumble Pie and both of them were absolutely amazing.
10/10 Highly recommend 👍🏻
B
Brandon A
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
9/26/24
• DoorDash order
I got the Sausage Burrata & Pesto it was insane. The flavor was so good, quality ingredients and the honey drizzle on the crust was a nice touch. The dough was perfect. Light and fluffy.
I work out of town so I read the reviews on this place and they did not steer me wrong. Best pizza I've had in my life, and I don't say that lightly.
I also got the Honey Roasted Strawberry gelato and it was incredible. It perfectly fit the flavor profile in the description. Next time I'm in town I'm going to this place in person. So worth the money.
B
Brandon M
1 contributions
6/28/24
• DoorDash order
Second time ordering. Got a 16 in. "Create Own" (huge pizza btw) and 8 oz. of gelato/ice cream. It was $29 for the pie, which is a decent price for good NY-style imo, and $10 for the ice cream (good but not worth). The pizza showed up cold (not entirely their fault), the crust was uneven in most spots and literally paper-thin in others, the chunks of sausage were massive (pretty much ruined it), pepperoni saved it, there was mayyybe a pinch of shrooms on the entire thing, and the thyme was overwhelming. The ice cream also showed up half-closed, completely melted, and overflowing everywhere (luckily dasher had napkins to clean and wrap it up before dropping off).
If I hadn't enjoyed the first order so much (tried their popular pepperoni "hot honey"), this would easily be 1-star. I've had my fair share of bad orders/refunds over the years, but this is the first time I've ever felt compelled enough to leave a review anywhere. Just how can you possibly mess up pizza and ice cream this bad?
While we're at it, the toppings on the cherry crumble pie were fine, but the crust was capable of breaking a tooth.
