One of Chicago's most popular pizzerias is Proper Pizza. This restaurant has been a Slice partner for one year and is a community staple. At this well-regarded eatery, choose the #1 Margherita Pizza f…
Amazing thin crust pizza with a unique poppy seed crust. I did a custom 16" with pepperoni and mushrooms, ate half for dinner and the other half for lunch the next day. reheated well at 400 degrees for 7 minutes
C
Carli P
3 contributions
10/1/23
• DoorDash order
The best pizza!!!! We love this spot so much, it is definitely our go to in Lincoln Park. It is delicious without being greasy or too heavy. The BBQ chicken is addicting. Crust is great and unique with sesame seeds. PLUS the owner is so sweet and gave us free drinks. HIGHLY recommend. Seriously cannot get it enough.
S
Sarah B
1 contributions
6/26/25
• DoorDash order
pizza was good and salad was huge! just wished dressing was on the side to ensure crispness and allow to save some for later. will adjust future order requests
D
Dylan L
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
12/2/22
• DoorDash order
Average pizza more cheddar than mozz
Not substantial, ingredient amounts equal that of a small pizza not a large
Came cold even though delivery was quick
Do they premake these then heat up?
Tenders flimsy and meatless
Disappointing
A
Ali A
3 contributions
5/23/23
• DoorDash order
Delicious flavorful pizzas! The owner made sure they were cooked properly himself, very nice man! Really recommend the proper pizza with the beef pepperoni! Some of the best beef, pepperoni/prosciutto you can find in Chicago
