It's my first time trying PSP and I like it! I ordered their 10" Pepperoni Lovers Pizza and I love how saucy and cheesy it was with the perfect amount of grease. Their crust is soft inside. I got full after two slices.
M
Monica B
Emerging Expert • 21 contributions
9/21/24
• DoorDash order
Pizza was meh...the crust was pretty bland and the toppings slid right off the pizza. The cheese balls were burnt on top and super tiny, which would've been fine if the pictures weren't misleading (cheese balls looked way bigger in the pictures). We won't be ordering from here again.
J
Jessica M
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
5/4/24
• DoorDash order
We ordered the 10" Hipster Pizza and 10" Hawaii Five-0 Pizza . They both had a lot of marinara sauce, kind of gushing from the pizza when we took bites. It was more sauce than we prefer. The toppings on both pizzas were good and there was a lot of them, but the marinara is heavily seasoned and the thin crust pizza dough is plain tasting and boring. I'm giving them 4 stars because they seem to use quality ingredients, and they don't skimp on the toppings, but the balance of flavors is off. I want to taste my toppings.
We also ordered the House Salad - Full . This was a good size and an easy split between two people for a side with the pizza. In addition we ordered the Garlic Cheese Bread . It was good. Very garlicky and cheesy.
D
Danielle C
1 contributions
5/10/25
• DoorDash order
I usually love this place. Paid a lot for burned pizza. The cookie and Cheese Balls - 10 Piece were good though!
C
Cary C
1 contributions
1/12/25
• DoorDash order
I love the St. Helens! Soooooo good. I order the gluten free as I have an intolerance I'm unfortunate to be saddled with and it never disappoints . Always a pleasure PSP!!!
