I had the Boston: 3-Way with Salt & Malt . My friends split the Chicago: Italian Beef and Los Angeles: French Dip with a large Garlic & Herb fries.
Prepared well and absolutely delicious all around.
I had previously given a 4 star based on an incorrect order and mentioned I would definitely be back to give the other star... I've been 3 times in the last week and it's been perfect each time. I met Aaron this afternoon when I picked up an order and he was super friendly. Love Roastys, excellent beefs!
J
Julianne N
Local Expert • 29 contributions
2/22/25
• DoorDash order
I really wanted to love this place but, unfortunately it fell short for me. Everything arrived freezing cold, but it's winter so it's not all that surprising and didn't factor into my rating. I ordered the Los Angeles: French Dip and sadly, there was no au jus with the sandwich. It wouldn't have been a huge deal but the roast beef was EXTREMELY dry while the roll was dripping wet. The fries are very thin but were also very dry and just over all not very good. The Toffee Chip Cookie was good, but not $6+ good. I expected it to be on the larger side for that price but it was just your average cookie.
I don't think I can justify ordering from here again when there are much better sandwich shops in the area.
A
Ace L
3 contributions
3/7/25
• DoorDash order
I never do reviews on DoorDash but I had to come back to say this place is amazing. I didn't want my food to end. I usually have to add salt to any Coleslaw I get from anywhere, except here. The Build-Your-Own with horseradish had me in a chokehold. I could eat here everyday for the rest of my life if my cholesterol could handle it. 10 out of 10. Easiest 5 star I've ever given.
T
Thomas P
2 contributions
2 days ago
• DoorDash order
Got the Philadelphia: Cheesesteak and the Chicago: Italian Beef. Gotta say, these sandwiches were stacked! Quite possibly one of the best steak sandwiches I've had in a long time. I'm not from Chicago, so o can't speak to the authenticity, but that beef sandwich with hot gardiniera was outta this world. It came with a horseradish mayo type sauce that was excellent. Will definitely be ordering again...and again!
C
Connie-Jo L
Emerging Expert • 27 contributions
12/15/24
• DoorDash order
I have a mixed first impression of this place. A con for every pro. Here's my honest review:
My Boston: 3-Way sandwich was huge, but very messy and hard to get out of the little delivery box. The meat was cooked perfectly, but the BBQ sauce is way too tangy/has to much kick (which is fine .. if I knew about that before I ordered it). The 'Shoestring Beast Style Fries ' taste good, but are not fires, they are like hash brown shavings. They needed more (yummy) cheese sauce too. The Philly: Cheese Steak was not eaten by me, so I don't know anything about it other than the person eating it said it was good.
