First time ordering from Rotolo's...fantastic! The lasagna is delicious, and way more than I can eat in one meal. A new favorite for me.
K
Kaye L
5 contributions
5/26/24
• DoorDash order
The burger was excellent. Cooked properly with broche bun, fried jalapeños & cheddar cheese,
Sweet potato fries were good.
Spagetti & meatballs were hot & good.
M
Marshell G
2 contributions
2/17/25
• DoorDash order
Alfredo has no flavor and garlic knots slimy
L
Leslie A
1 contributions
1/5/25
• DoorDash order
Food arrived hot and fresh! Rotolo's In-House Lasagna was delicious!!! I think this might just be my new favorite. I appreciate them wrapping my garlic parmesan bites separately. We also ordered the Fried Shrimp Alfredo. They kept the shrimp in a separate box to keep it from getting mushy. It seems like the people at Rotolo's really cared about cooking and packing up our order. It is becoming a rare thing, and I really appreciate it! We will definitely order from Rotolo's again!
S
Sheri M
Emerging Expert • 33 contributions
12/24/24
• DoorDash order
This was our 2nd deep dish order from you, hoping it would improve after the first experience. The taste of the Windy City (Deep Dish) pizza (& the other one) was fine, but the size & prize are OUTRAGEOUS! You can buy a full-size (aka "Large") AUTHENTIC deep dish pizza from Lou Malnati's or Giordano's IN CHICAGO for under $30 & it would serve FOUR (4) PEOPLE!
Plus, the bottom crust is so wet & soggy it soaks completely through the bottom of the box & leaks all over everything! You could at least put a liner underneath it - if you can't bother to cook it properly!
The Side Salad (Garden) was about five bites.
We'll drive to Chicago for deep dish before wasting our time & money here again. Sorry.
