"The Sapienza Bake Shop began in 1935, when Andrew Sapienza bought a grocery business in Queens' Corona district.
Paul bought the store outright in 1973 and renamed it Sapienza Bake Shop.
The 1 Lb of assorted sandwich cookies were so fresh! They mel in my mo Delicious.
A
Ashley D
5 contributions
11/5/22
• DoorDash review
My son really enjoyed his birthday cake and it actually served a good amount of guests. I appreciate the baker adding the happy birthday message I requested. Very well packaged and tasted amazing
P
Phillip C
9 contributions
9/10/23
• DoorDash order
A definite neighborhood favorite. Never heard a bad thing about the place. The only bakery in the mecham ave/ Hempstead tpk area that lasted 50 years.
I believe they originally had a bakery in Brooklyn prior to coming to Elmont.
Give it shot
S
Shalanda D
6 contributions
5/14/25
• DoorDash order
I never have problems with the cakes I purchase from here. This time I do not know what happened to this cake but it tasted like chemicals.
R
Rosemarie L
8 contributions
3/5/24
• DoorDash order
Cake was good, but the frosting was very disappointing, and not what I expected. The buttercream did not taste or look like buttercream.
