Patriarch J. Fred Schmidt, born just north of Frankfurt, Germany, immigrated to America in the early 1880s and resided in south Columbus. Schmidt's Meat Packing House, which opened in 1886 in the cent…
They also have me a bunch of mustards and horseradish to go with the Old World Sausage Sampler! Speaking of it was very nice that they wrapped up the bread so it wouldn't get soggy! The Potato Pancakes were nice and crisp and the Apple Strudel was an awesome choice for the dessert considering I dont think I could have finished one of their cream puffs! As always it was delicious, 10/10
D
Dan G
1 contributions
1/27/25
• DoorDash order
seems like when I went to pickup, they were slammed and my sandwich and onions were undercooked. I've had it from their food truck and it was perfect, crispy sausage and bun. I'd recommend their food truck unless they're not busy at restaurant.
D
Dante S
Local Expert • 80 contributions
11/29/23
• DoorDash order
The best thing was that I asked for no cheese and they honored that. otherwise, nowhere near as much Traditional Corned Beef Reuben meat as the photo depicts. If anything, there was more sauerkraut than anything. And the corned beef wasn't particularly flavorful either. What was left on my taste buds was sauerkraut and rye or pumpernickel bread. Nowhere near worth $16. Not tryna bash local restaurants but just do better by the people spending their $$
M
Matthew B
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
10/16/22
• DoorDash order
Heaven for Germans and all others who lover German food. Their Bratwurst Sandwich is the best. German potato salad rivals Charlie the Butcher's in Buffalo. So tasty. If I lived in Columbus I would dash this place multiple times a week. Unfortunately I live in Youngstown. Nothing like this place there. But hey!, our pizza is really good!
S
Susan L
Local Expert • 41 contributions
5/29/24
• DoorDash order
The food was well-packaged and hot when I got it. Dasher read the directions and put it next the front door instead of on the porch steps.
The Bahama Mama was spicy and the bread was wrapped separately so it wasn't soggy. It would be great if other stores would do that when possible. The German potato salad was good, The cherry cheese tart tasted a little different that it did when I had it a few years ago but it was very good. It could have used a few more cherries but that's a personal preference.
