The Short Rib Ravioli was fantastic and worth the high price. I chose the recommended mushroom sauce.
Z
Zergio R
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
6/19/25
• DoorDash order
I don't usually post reviews about the foods that I order but this is not getting the recognition it deserves, the Calamari was so good it was perfectly cooked and seasoned and still crispy when it arrived where a lot of restaurants struggle on doing. Would recommend this 100%
N
Nat L
Local Expert • 69 contributions
9/15/24
• DoorDash order
Selma's used to be a lot better. Simply not worth the price. The Italian Chopped Salad (Regular) was SOO small for $15, and there was BARELY any meat or cheese :( The calzone was decent, but it's ridiculous that it says that it comes with TWO toppings yet you can only add one for free and have to pay extra for more than one. Hardly any toppings fit in there anyway, so it seems silly to upcharge an extra $1-$2 for extra. Regret spending $40 on two things that were decent at best.
J
Jessica G
16 contributions
1/1/22
• DoorDash order
It was pretty good the sauce was excellent however the bread did not feel fresh. Tasted like it was cooked twice. Tony's Little Italy Cook their Chicago pizza fresh. If you cook yours fresh I would give you five star but not sure if I will go here again. The price is not too bad either
S
Sabina R
6 contributions
3/9/24
• DoorDash review
we love doordashing our selmas. pizzas are insanely good cheesy and sauce. always nice and hot. only 1 time when we ordered right before they closed did we receive the wrong pizza. if youre looming for that cheesy pizza selmas is for you
