4.3(4k+ ratings)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.3(4k+ ratings)•
$$•Pizzeria
Shelly Farren, Mike Aiello, and Jim Holland, longtime friends, decided to launch Shelly Pie on the spur of the moment.
The three of them make up the ownership that gives Shelly Pie its distinct style!…
Full Menu
11:00 am - 6:40 pmMost Liked Items From The Menu
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Most Liked Items From The Menu
Reviews4k+ ratings • 100+ public reviews
4.3
of 5 stars
B
Bonnie D
9 contributions2/28/25
• DoorDash orderWould be 5 stars but I didnt receive the extra sauce that I paid $1.04 to get but otherwise everything is delicious and as ordered.
J
Justin M
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions3/5/25
• DoorDash orderTuna Melt and Fish on the Fish Sandwich were great! Bread was chewy, presumably because it was hot and then became wet from the steam inside the box.
Fries are not the greatest, soggy and cold when arrived but mostly expected with delivered frozen fries.
"Extra Large" dressing is simply a normal sized sauce cup.
A
Ashton D
2 contributions11/8/24
• DoorDash orderOh. My. God. This is officially a new family favorite!!!! The Garlic Knots are SO GOOD!!!! The pizza is fantastic as well! I am so pleased with the quality and am very appreciative that they called to let me know one of the items was out instead of just replacing it with something I didn't want.
Italian Greens & Beans were good as well! Almost like my Nonis!
A
Ashley P
1 contributions12/26/23
• DoorDash orderShlly is Pie is always a win! The pizza is cheesy and thecl crust is soft and chewy and delicious! The wings are flavorful and oh so good! I highly suggest their ranch and garlic dip/sauce. It's extra but it's delicious on wings, pizza, chicken tenders, everything!
J
Judi F
12 contributions10/11/23
• DoorDash orderEverything was delicious! I wouldn't mind a little more bolognese sauce over the noodles and you can skip the melted bed of cheese on top. Just a couple suggestions but it was still awesome!