Strawberry Banana PuddingBiscoff Banana PuddingCaramel Banana Pudding was ordered and it's just exquisite. The texture is perfect and flavor wise it's not overly sweet. Look forward to getting some more soon
M
Mika R
Local Expert • 37 contributions
3/22/25
• DoorDash order
Biscoff Cookie Croffle was very good and different- I would recommend trying it.
The Original Banana Pudding - I am not a fan -- it was super sweet with more heavy cream than pudding-seems more of a filling. Will not order that again- For the price- it's a small serving of whip.
The Biscoff Banana Pudding is for my son- it looks good and appears to have more filling... not just a cup of cream. Still small for the price.
I am willingto try itherdessrts offered- just not the overpriced cream cup of Original Banana Pudding
T
Tricia S
5 contributions
5/18/24
• DoorDash order
Everything I have had at The Puddery is excellent!! From service to these amazing puddings. I have had strawberry pudding and croffles which are my favorites as well as the banana, caramel and Oreo Cookie Banana Pudding!!! They don't miss! Not too sweet and just right!!!
R
Rj F
13 contributions
5/14/23
• DoorDash order
The Caramel Banana Pudding and Original Banana Pudding are very tasty. But where I paid for 4 - 16oz puddings and received 8 oz puddings that cost $35. I would appreciate getting whati paid for. I have been a repeat customer since i found this place
J
James B
1 contributions
5/6/25
• DoorDash order
The Original Banana Pudding was good, but not life changing.
My wife liked the Plain Ole Chocolate.
The Biscoff Cookie Croffle was literally the best thing I've ever eaten in my life. It was so good, I thought about driving over to their store to say thanks and shake somebody's hand for a job well done. Overall, 100% recommend.
