The Pasta and Sauce is great. I got penne pasta with creamy pesto - absolutely delicious! Mama's Meatballs were also delicious! You get four medium size meatballs. The Tomatina's Signature Garlic Rolls are good, but come soaked in too much olive oil. Took off a star for the high delivery fee and increased food prices.
C
Cherine K
4 contributions
4/28/24
• DoorDash order
The chicken was spiced and very moist. Second time my Alfredo sauce had separated. I did not reheat it because I learned to definitely not do that on my first order. The sauce has broken on each occasion (ordered 3 times before this review). Very disappointing because the first few bites are great. In addition the portion is very small for the price.
S
Samariya S
1 contributions
12/25/23
• DoorDash order
So I ordered the creamy pesto spaghetti and added salmon for $5.50. There's barely any salmon in here, pretty much what you see in this picture is all that's in there. The pasta is alright and tastes good, I have had better but it's fine. I'm mostly disappointed in the amount of salmon given.
D
DELIVER TO DOOR G
Emerging Expert • 18 contributions
9/8/23
• DoorDash order
Penne Bolognese was delicious, and I loved the Cesar salad with anchovies. Was VERY disappointed with the garlic rolls because of the bread consistency. They were large, which was ok, but the bread was more like a thick 3" end of a dry sourdough cornmeal pizza. Not breadlike at all and nothing like what I expected. In comparison, this was the opposite of an Olive Garden breadstick which I love.
T
T B
1 contributions
2/4/25
• DoorDash order
Terrible communication and they have a hard time processing orders correctly. My family and I don't eat meat so I always order Fettuccine Alfredo without meat but the last three times including this time they have still put meat in it. I spoke with the manager the last time I ordered and she blamed it on DoorDash stating that when they sent over the order it says with meat, okay. She advised me to call them the next time I place a order to let them know so I don't have any issues. So, today I ordered and I called and asked them to please make sure to not add meat. Sadly, when I got my order tonight it had meat in it and guess what? My husband pointed out that the receipt states Fettuccine Alfredo w/o Chicken. So no, this is not DoorDash's fault it's Tomatina's fault again. And instead of remaking it correctly a note was on the top of the Fettuccine Alfredo container (see attached photo). Oh, and the rolls were overcooked and hard along with the vegetables and beans in the Minestrone Soup were hard.
Local businesses are complaining about the drop in business and revenue but when the business is operating like this, can you really blame people for not visiting the establishment? No to mention, it's expensive eating out and additionally, who wants their time wasted like this?
I've finally given up on Tomatina. I have no faith things will get better here but I do wish them the best!
