The chicken marsala is very tasty and a pretty big meal. The chicken parm is almost as good as my husband's Sicilian grandma's. The pizza is some of the best we've had in the area and the restaurant takes a lot of care to give you quality (even for delivery). It's the little things like packing the basil for the margherita pizza separately so it doesn't wilt. I definitely recommend this place.
H
Hazel E
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
12/28/24
• DoorDash order
Large Shiitake & Sausage Pizza
How I Ordered It:
As is, with added sautéed spinach, basil, bell pepper, fresh mozzarella, and a crispy crust.
Price:
Base price is reasonable for the portion, but additional toppings felt overpriced. It might make more sense to scale prices based on ingredient costs, like charging more for mozzarella than bell peppers or basil, depending on seasonality.
Flavor:
The crust was perfectly crunchy—an ideal balance between thin and thick. I couldn’t really taste the fontina, likely overshadowed by the mozzarella, and I wish there had been more shiitake. That said, the combination of basil, fennel sausage, caramelized onion, and bell pepper was fantastic: warm, herby, sweet, and savory. Personally, I’d prefer the basil baked in, either under the cheese or added immediately after baking for a less raw flavor.
I’d order this again, but only when dining in.
A
Aminah C
Emerging Expert • 24 contributions
5/4/25
• DoorDash order
The Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo was meh- The sauce was super thin and did not stick to the pasta at all. - there is no way they used cream or thickened it with parmesan or anything. Cream sauce from the store without adding garlic or onion or salt is better. The Tomatina's Housemade Garlic Rolls (4) were good. For the price I would not order here again.
B
Brandon C
Emerging Expert • 19 contributions
10/1/23
• DoorDash order
Sauce could definitely use a little more imagination for a $20 restaurant pasta, tastes like any off the shelf grocery store sauce and it isn't expensive to spice and season. The meatballs on the other hand are pretty flavorful. The sauce could certainly be less watery
D
Dana L
5 contributions
8/4/22
• DoorDash order
Great food. Feeds many. I'm our case, it allows for leftovers for a few days. The meatballs are always really delicious. Great salad & garlic rolls Packed well.
