Not sure why I'm giving it 4 Stars, it arrived cold and limp(?), but the pepperoni had a little bite to them, the sauce was good with pretty decent hints of garlic, and the cheese wasn't too much. If it would've arrived warm it, it would taste like New Haven pizza.
B
Brandon M
1 contributions
11/18/24
• DoorDash order
Sauce needs work, im guessing the sauce was over cooked making the ingredients go bitter.
S
Sue e
2 contributions
10/10/24
• DoorDash review
2 awful experiences. This place used to be good a year ago. we had our friends over for dinner. We said what good food Tony's had. The pizza came burnt underneath. Crust was hard as a rock. Last week I ordered again. I called and asked them not to burn this one. I told them what had happened. The man said no problem, they won't overcook it. Well, It received it exactly same condition as they earlier burnt one. I'm so upset. I will NEVER order from them again!
K
Kerri C
3 contributions
7/24/24
• DoorDash order
We normally love their pizza.. today is was greasy and disgusting
M
Mary M
8 contributions
1/18/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered from the wrong Tony's New York Pizza this is Tony's New York Pizza and pasta not Tony's New York Pizza the food tastes like it was a frozen meal put in the the microwave the chicken taste like it was frozen it wasn't fried it tastes like it was frozen and thrown in the microwave jar sauce nothing good about this place so sorry I ordered from it by accident wasted $30
