My biggest concern with food was not being able to find a good pizza when I recently moved from "Joisey" to Ft Myers. I'm happy to say that I've found the perfect NY/NJ pie at Tony's NY Pizza. Not only is the pizza the bomb but the Antipasto Salad and Zeppolis are out of this world! Now if anyone has a reccomendation for bagels hit me up ;-)
R
R K
Local Expert • 287 contributions
2/6/25
• DoorDash order
the Eggplant Parmesan consisted of a lot of penne with a ring of 6 fried eggplant rounds on top. the sauce was shredded canned tomatoes that must've had almost no simmer time they were so acidic. the garlic rolls were underdone - solid lumps of dough. the salad was good but had the wrong dressing. not sure what the Soup of Day was, but it was decent.
R
R K
Local Expert • 287 contributions
2/20/25
• DoorDash order
Soup of Day was gawd awful - broth was salty dishwater with a few chopped up meat balls, some green leafy stuff and a gre carrots. 25¢ worth of horrendous ingredients. salty salty salty. the side. salad was very good.. the 12" Sausage Pepper & Onions was only fair. the marinara sauce was only squashed tomatoes, no sauce. the onions and peppers were totally raw.
R
R K
Local Expert • 287 contributions
5/24/25
• DoorDash order
wish Side Garden Salad were larger for the cost. sausage is good wish it came with a bit more sauce.
P
Paige B
11 contributions
11/24/24
• DoorDash order
This is the absolute BEST Pizza in SW Florida !!! Im from up North and haven't found place from up home. Been here 4 years!! If you like thin crust pizza NY SYLE.. this is your place!!!! They make all the sauces... everything is made fresh everyday!!! I stumbled across this restaurant by doing deliveries.... ITS AMAZING!! You wont be disappointed!!! Yum Yum!!!!!
