Whole Pies are 9x9" and usually feed 2-3 people.
Most pizzas come with red sauce on the side.
The only pizzas that are baked with red sauce are the Red and the Margherita
Probably my favorite in Bham! As others have mentioned, do NOT be fooled by "tiny" size. 9x9 has been enough for 2 very hungry people (and had leftovers) every time. Also, I love the cup of marinara that comes with the pizza because it's perfection.
A
Arleen C
Local Expert • 162 contributions
8/26/23
• DoorDash order
Pizza was very yummy! It came in the 9"x9" size which we were not certain would be filling enough for 2 people but it was plenty enough for a couple of slices of leftovers too -- we love leftover pizza!!! Don't let the price fool you, you will get plenty for your money -- you definitely get a great and filling meal for their 9"x9" size. The crust is thick and soaks up all the good flavors. Best part was that the scrumptious pizza sauce came on the side so we could dip the crust and make it more than just yummy bread. The carmalized edges are the BEST!!! Will definitely be ordering again and again!!!
R
Ruby J
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
5/18/25
• DoorDash order
The NY Style crust was so delicious, really was close to the crust I grew up eating in Detroit subs. Spicy pepperoni — absolutely delicious. Pan Pie never disappoints. Love these guys!!
J
Jas R
1 contributions
11/30/22
• DoorDash order
The pizza is really good, but the price for a whole pie vs what you get is ridiculous. It says somewhere on the site that it can feed 2 - 4 people, and that's not even remotely true. It can feed 2 at most... and thats being generous. If it was priced appropriately, it'd get five stars.
M
Matt L
3 contributions
9/5/22
• DoorDash order
Slices are small for being 10$ each but tastes very good
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Whole Pies (Most w/ Sauce on Side)
Whole Pies are 9x9" and usually feed 2-3 people.
Most pizzas come with red sauce on the side. The only pizzas that are baked with red sauce are the Red and the Margherita