I'm new in town and this place was open on Thanksgiving. The Omnivore was very good. The toppings were chunky, flavorful, and fresh. I really enjoyed the pizza sauce that came on it and the beef sausage gave the pizza a very unique and delicious flavor. The 6 Wings with garlic parmesan sauce were slightly overcooked but still good. As for the Fried Mushrooms, they were nothing special or unique but if you like them at other places you will like these. The NY Giant Cheesecake was a huge piece and was very rich and creamy. Plenty of leftovers for tomorrow too. I will definitely order all of this again.
2+
J
John A
1 contributions
7/25/24
• DoorDash order
I was wxle it to be pre plain but my goodness it was delicious spectacular yall should try it out
H
Hayden H
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
9/15/23
• DoorDash order
Awesome flavor on the cheesesteak and fries, great seasoning all around. The cheese was also plentiful but not over flowing or too greasy. Will order again!
L
Lacy B
13 contributions
12/17/22
• DoorDash order
This is literally my go-to place! it's always so delicious! the mozzarella sticks are hands down the best I've ever had from anywhere! the pizza is absolutely perfect every time! It has the perfect amount of sauce to crust to cheese ratio. I can't rave about Valentinos enough
A
Ashley A
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
3/27/22
• DoorDash review
I would give it five stars except, the margarita pizza had so little cheese and Basil it was more like a sauce pizza. The Hawaiian was really good, loaded with ingredients. The crust is yummy, the sauce is yummy but you have to balance out that margarita pizza!