This is a 9.2 pizza and in the same conversation as Delucia's in Raritan and Ralph's Pizza in Nutely. Order it with a well-done crust and ask for a crispy undercarriage. In my calculations, a pizza has 4 categories with max 2.5pts for each: Undercarriage, Sauce, Cheese, and End-crust. The Undercarriage is a 2.3 (crispy, well-done bar pie), Sauce is a 2.1 with just the right amount but no real distinct flavor that jumps out (not as incredible as Delucia's for example), the Cheese is a 2.3 (delicious, just the right amount, and they even got some on the end-crust). Total is a 9.2
A
Alex P
1 contributions
10/11/24
• DoorDash review
Some of the best pizza around. Order ahead because it's so popular. Will keep coming back!!
A
Ali B
Emerging Expert • 34 contributions
8/16/24
• DoorDash order
Pizza was good but salty and expensive. Salad was nothing special and very pricey for the portion received.
K
Kate E
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
12/18/22
• DoorDash order
The Gramps pizza is the best pizza around. Vinnie's is far but the wait and reheat at home is always worth it over our local spots. So good!
M
Margaret B
3 contributions
2/17/22
• DoorDash order
The pepperoni pizza is really tasty, as are the salads - particularly their House Salad with goat cheese, pears, dried cranberries and walnuts. We also like their soups which are perfect for lunch the next day.
